I'm sorry, I ment I have Sound Forge 7 and NR 2, but I can't find the clipped peak restoration tool. Is that an add on to noise redux? Would it even help me?
- Posts: 534
- Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 5:00 am
It should be under DX Favorites/Sonic Foundry (along with quite a few others that came with NR 2)
Theoretically it should help (I think)... and I am in an identical situation myself with a wireless MIC someone used in a recording where the mic was not attenuated with the transmitter and the signal was peaking. The audio, like yours never reaches above -3db in the file and yet the audio is distorted. Zooming in using SF you can see the lovely square peaks (strangely always on the lower side of the "wave").
I tried using the clipped peak tool and it seems to make little diferrence (which could mean I am using it wrong... or my ears just aren't that sensitive..and/or the audio is just too far gone for the FX to recover it). There is a reference in the help which says the FX is only for "occasionally" clipped audio and that if the audio is excessively clipped that it will not help.
If you figure it out and your audio is improved.. let me know as I would love to be able to "fix" this audio as well.
Clipped peak does come with the NR package... so you should have it as well. All the FX's are called Sonic Foundry XXXX e.g. Sonic Foundry Noise Reduction, Sonif Foundry Clipped Peak.
- Posts: 510
- Joined: Tue Jun 05, 2007 4:05 pm
If eighter of you haven't, read the PFD help file. It REALLY helps.
I've used the NR 2 pack in Vegas (only have that el-cheap SF that came with Screenblast Acid & it doesn't support plugins). The clipped peak tool will work on abunch of waveforms at once, but they can't be too far gone. I've used it to fix clipps in recordings from the 50's on reel to reel. Works good.
- Posts: 502
- Joined: Sun Aug 27, 2006 10:42 pm
I've also checked my waves in SF and there is definitely clipping, even at -12db. I have no explanation for that. The level on the DAT I recorded with was set to about 1 (out of 10).
So far the clipped peak thing isn't helping, but I need to more research. Any tips are certainly appreciated as are explanations why my audio clipped at such a safe level.
Thanks Liam and TheHappyFriar. I misunderstood the help commands in SF and was opening the noise reduction plugin looking for a setting in it rather than a seperate plugin. Not quite sure why mention the cd when that's not the place to look. But then again, I haven't slept since thursday, so it might be me.
- Posts: 511
- Joined: Thu Aug 16, 2007 5:19 am
Just as an example, wireless mics have a transmitter, now if the mic level is way too high then the front end of the transmitter is going to clip the signal right up front. Conversely if the level going in is way too low you'll get more noice than you should.
Same thing can happen at the reciever end, if you're coming out of there too hot you'll overload the front end of the next stage in the chain.
I think the Sennheisers have a level meter on the transmitter, checking that you're getting the right sort of levels there can really help.
Also you need to know what meters are reading, mostly these days they seem to read peak but you never know!
Thats why it always pays to monitor with closed back headphones when you're recording, better still do a test recording and listen to it carefully. Track I find when listening is to close your eyes and press the cans hard against your head to get the brain really focused on the sound from the cans. If the sound in the cans is bad but the ambient good it seems our brain just blocks out what its hearing from the cans and this seems to be more so when we are getting visual cues.
I think the trick with clippered peak restoration is telling it at what level the peaks that are clipped are at. . I've only played with it briefly and the clipped detection tool as well, you can use that to see if you've got things setup right and then pur the values you used there into the restoration FX.
I'd need to know HOW the recording was made to tell you how you got clipping. But in general even though the recording devices isn't showing clipping it can happen before it gets to the recorder.
- Posts: 502
- Joined: Wed Oct 24, 2007 4:48 pm
Sounds like something was clipping the signal before it got to your DAT machine. What was your signal chain? Mic into a mixer first? Right into the DAT? The problem with clipping in digital...once it's clipped, it's clipped. As apposed to anolog where a little clipping was good, gave a natural tape compression. Not all pieces of gear have level meters, so you really gotta be careful when setting levels in the signal chain.
- Posts: 482
- Joined: Wed Dec 20, 2006 10:33 pm
I should have read farss' post first...he says it very well
- Posts: 486
- Joined: Thu Nov 30, 2006 10:05 am
Any thoughts on what could be the problem? Is there any way to use the pencil tool to fix things if it comes to it?
Thanks again for the help.
It was mic directly into the DAT. The mic was a Sennheiser ME66 and the cable was 25'. I don't think the cable ran over any electric wires, if that helps.
- Posts: 513
- Joined: Mon Apr 02, 2007 7:32 pm
Hmm ME66, think that's the mic you can either put a battery in OR run off phantom power. If it's the one I'm thinking of then having the battery in and phantom power on causes no end of problems.
If it's not the one, you could have succeeded in simply overloading the mic.
May be really stupid question, are you 100% certain it's clipping?
I guess if you're that far into it your pretty damn certain, just that I've fretted over what sounded like something clipping but it wasn't, just the way the guy's voice sounded.
Come to think of it you mentioned only the negative peaks were clipped, hm, maybe something wierd was happening in the mic, speech oftenly has more negative than positive peaks but for it to be enough to cuase clipping in one direction is odd. You can use SF to see if you do have a DC offset, I though those problems only afflicted very old A/D converters.
You can use SF to find the clipped peaks, I seem to recall it marks them as regions and then you could use the pencil tool to draw a rounded top on them to at least get rid of the harmonics. That would be a HUGE effort though, I think I'd be spending a bit of time getting clipped peak restoration to do the job.
- Posts: 482
- Joined: Tue Aug 29, 2006 12:22 pm
musman, could you post a link to a 3-5 second clip (mp3 high quality) that we culd take a look at?
- Posts: 455
- Joined: Tue Jun 20, 2006 7:33 am
5 seconds will not be that big.
Just thinking the same but why not a .wav?
- Posts: 475
- Joined: Fri Sep 15, 2006 12:36 am
I double checked and the clipping is at the top and bottom of the waves. The ME66 didn't have the battery power running but was using the phantom power from the DAT. The DAT's limiter was not on. So again, I really don't get it. Maybe I was wrong and The mic cable intersected the power cord of the DAT as it was not running on battery. Don't know if that makes a difference.
I'd love to post a section of the clip on my web site, but I only know how to use the basic builder that comes with the hosting, and I don't think it allows audio to be added. I could email a 5 sec bit of it or create an email address and pu it there and post the password.
Would anyone be willing to put up with that?
Thanks again for all the help!
Thanks for interest and help. Sorry I didn't respond earlier. Didn't sleep thursday night getting these things ready for the festival.
- Posts: 505
- Joined: Fri Mar 30, 2007 6:25 am
I suggested mp3 because i'm on a dialup.
you can e-mail it to me @ the_Happy_friar
- Posts: 499
- Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 4:41 am